fake X
A person A, who does not have a proper understanding of X, provides inappropriate education about X, which causes person B, who is educated about X, to have negative feelings toward X (rather than toward A), human bug.
---
For example, there are two types of criticism of "PDCA" (whatever that means): criticism of "fake PDCA" which is not PDCA in the first place, using the term PDCA, and criticism of the side effects caused by achieving PDCA, which are There is a complete difference between the two.
https://twitter.com/rashita2/status/1274141158692622336
nishio.icon
Someone who clearly does not understand "PDCA" (not only PDCA, but any value can be substituted) pushes "fake PDCA" on the back of authority such as internal training, etc. The person who is forced to do so accumulates hate and criticizes "PDCA," but that person also believes that the "fake PDCA" he was taught is "PDCA," and the situation turns into a totally sterile argument... The composition of the debate is completely sterile...
Patterns in which the person playing the "teaching role" does not really understand the content of what he or she is teaching.
Often, for some reason, the criticism is directed at the content, not the person.
In general, it's a hurdle because you need to know you're getting it right in order to realize that the teacher is teaching you the wrong thing.
But not so much when it comes to practical skills.
You wouldn't trust a "programming instructor who hasn't created his own programs" or a "design thinking instructor who hasn't designed his own stuff."
Practical technical knowledge can be verified as to whether or not the understanding is correct by whether or not beneficial results have been obtained by putting it into practice. Verification of understanding
Instructors who do not practice do not verify that their understanding is correct, so they teach with the wrong understanding.
src
relevance
Hate beneficial things because of stupid educators.
Formal Why-Why Analysis
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/なんちゃってX using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.